Donald Rumsfeld Condemns False Newsweek Story on Koran Flushing: You Can't Apologize to the Dead
Former Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld appeared on Tuesday's Hannity
and recounted the harm Newsweek did in 2005 with a false report about
U.S. soldiers flushing a Koran down the toilet at Guantanamo Bay.
Discussing the story with host Sean Hannity, he complained, "Later
[Newsweek] said 'if part of our story wasn't correct, we apologize.' Of
course, the people they were apologizing to were dead. Now, how does
that happen?" 15 people died in rioting resulting from the
article. Rumsfeld lamented, "Well, I suppose people want to be first
instead of accurate and that's too bad."
He added, "Of course, a lie races around the world 15 times before the
truth even gets its boots on." Rumsfeld, who was promoting his new book,
also appeared on Monday's World News, Nightline and Tuesday's Good
Morning America. None of those ABC hosts questioned the ex-Defense
Secretary about Newsweek's false story or the impact it had on America.
Instead, GMA host George Stephanopoulos pushed Rumsfeld to apologize for not supporting a troop surge, ignoring the fact that many in the media mocked the idea of such an increase.
The MRC's Brent Baker, on May 16, 2005, explained how Newsweek buried its apology:
Newsweek may have admitted Sunday that its sloppy reporting, about how a U.S. soldier at Guantanamo Bay flushed a Koran down a toilet, led to riots in Afghanistan which killed at least 15 people, but they hardly made their concession prominent in the May 23 edition of the magazine, especially online where, on the magazine's home page, you'd have to guess that this headline, "The Islamic World: How a Fire Broke Out," had something to do with a retraction. And to read Editor Mark Whitaker's message, you'd have to know to click on "Letters and Live Talk" in a left side column, then, under "More," choose "The Editors' Desk." And even then, whether online or in the hard copy, Whitaker didn't approach an apology until the last sentence of his last paragraph: "We regret that we got any part of our story wrong, and extend our sympathies to victims of the violence and to the U.S. soldiers caught in its midst."
On September 10, 2010, MSNBC's Richard Wolffe, who also writes for Newsweek, repeated the debunked claims.
A transcript of the exchange, which occurred on February 8 at 9:50EST, follows:
- Scott Whitlock is a news analyst for the Media Research Center. Click here to follow him on Twitter.HANNITY: But, you did say this: You said "the irresponsible reporting of the media was harmful to our troops, as they were trying to build relationships with the Iraqi citizens." It wasn't just them, it was senators, surge failed, war is lost, they are killing innocent civilians in the dark of night. That was John Kerry on "Face The Nation."
RUMSFELD: Yes, you know, the worst, one of the worst was the statement in the press that someone in Guantanamo had flushed the Koran down the toilet.
HANNITY: You write about that.
RUMSFELD: In the book I talk about that because there were riots in several cities and people were killed. Totally untrue, it never happened.
HANNITY: "Newsweek."
RUMSFELD: Exactly. Later they said if part of our story wasn't correct, we apologize. Of course, the people they were apologizing to were dead. Now, how does that happen? Well, I suppose people want to be first instead of accurate and that's too bad. I've never been in that business so I can't be critical of them. I just don't know what I would do. I was hard to see those kinds of things said. Of course, a lie races around the world 15 times before the truth even gets its boots on.
HANNITY: It's true.
