CBS Features Rescued Iraqi Surgeon: 'Thank You American Military' --1/16/2007


1. CBS Features Rescued Iraqi Surgeon: 'Thank You American Military'
Monday's CBS Evening News featured a recounting, by Lara Logan, of how over the weekend U.S. Army soldiers rescued an Iraqi surgeon and his family who were trapped for eight days on Baghdad's Haifa Street, suffering in dire conditions and in danger of getting killed in fighting between Sunni militias and the Iraqi army. After the rescue, Dr. Quraish Fajir al-Kasir proclaimed on camera: "These are days that I will never forget in my life. Thank you American military, thank you people!" The "Crazyhorse" troops of the 4th Squadron, 9th Cavalry of the U.S. Army conducted the mission after the U.S. Ambassador to Iraq saw CBS's Friday story on the plight of Dr. al-Kasir, a very prominent Iraqi doctor who once attended a meeting at the White House.

2. "Bush Cheered at Fort Benning" v "Bush Speaks & Base Is Subdued"
"Are There Two Different Fort Bennings?" So asked James Taranto in his Friday "Best of the Web Today" compilation for Opinion Journal.com as he cited an AP story posted on ABCNews.com with the headline, "Bush Cheered at Fort Benning," while the New York Times headline declared: "Bush Speaks and Base Is Subdued."

3. CBS Ignores Lower Count and Hypes Most Dire Homeless Guesstimate
Two days after the National Alliance to End Homelessness released its survey which estimated that in January of 2005, "744,313 people experienced homelessness," the CBS Evening News on Friday picked an earlier, more dire, guesstimate covering an entire year from the group with a self-interest in making homelessness seem as ominous as possible. Introducing an "Assignment America" piece from Steve Hartman on a homeless shelter in Gloucester, Massachusetts that "could be a museum, or at least a bed and breakfast" since it's "350 years old and beautifully restored," fill-in anchor Russ Mitchell declared, "It's a sad truth: Too many Americans don't have a house to call their own. Over the course of any year, some 600,000 families find themselves homeless, and that includes more than 1.3 million children." On screen, viewers saw matching numbers attributed to the National Alliance to End Homelessness, but in a study released on Wednesday, the group reported that its month-long survey located "98,452 homeless families."

4. Time Trashed Flat Tax in '96, Now Flat Tax Boom In Eastern Europe
More than a decade after publisher Steve Forbes's flat-tax platform temporarily vaulted him to the top of the pack of GOP presidential candidates, another prospective Republican presidential candidate is making tax simplification a centerpiece of his 2008 campaign. In announcing his exploratory committee, Kansas Senator Sam Brownback argued, "We need a flat tax instead of the dreadful, incomprehensible tax code we now have," Monday's Wichita Eagle reported. But unlike back in 1996, the media are now confronted with the evidence that the flat tax help boost wealth-producing economic growth. This week's Time reports on the economic boom in the former Soviet republic of Estonia, which like many Eastern European countries has seen its fortunes rise since dumping socialism and instituting a flat tax. "The economy is now one of Europe's most dynamic, racing along at an 11.3% growth clip," Peter Gumbel writes this week in his "Letter from Estonia." Nearly eleven years ago, Time took dead aim at Forbes's flat tax in a January 29, 1996 cover package, "Does the Flat Tax Make Any Sense," an issue which hit mailboxes right before the New Hampshire primary.

5. "Top Ten Surprises in President Bush's 60 Minutes Interview"
Letterman's "Top Ten Surprises in President Bush's 60 Minutes Interview."


CBS Features Rescued Iraqi Surgeon: 'Thank
You American Military'

Monday's CBS Evening News featured a recounting, by Lara Logan, of how over the weekend U.S. Army soldiers rescued an Iraqi surgeon and his family who were trapped for eight days on Baghdad's Haifa Street, suffering in dire conditions and in danger of getting killed in fighting between Sunni militias and the Iraqi army. After the rescue, Dr. Quraish Fajir al-Kasir proclaimed on camera: "These are days that I will never forget in my life. Thank you American military, thank you people!" The "Crazyhorse" troops of the 4th Squadron, 9th Cavalry of the U.S. Army conducted the mission after the U.S. Ambassador to Iraq saw CBS's Friday story on the plight of Dr. al-Kasir, a very prominent Iraqi doctor who once attended a meeting at the White House.

[This item was posted Monday night on the MRC's blog, NewsBusters.org: newsbusters.org ]

The CBSNews.com online version of the story: www.cbsnews.com

A transcript of Logan's piece from Baghdad as aired on the January 15 CBS Evening News, picking up after Logan re-capped her January 12 report on how al-Kasir's family was trapped, a report she based on a phone call with him:

Lara Logan: "....The famous surgeon, once a guest of President Bush at the White House, was now hiding in a dark bathroom with his wife and three children, shivering from cold and hunger."
Audio of Dr. Quraish Fajir al-Kasir in phone call with Logan last week: "I have saved so many people in surgery, I have done a lot for the people here. Why I should be killed, why? I don't know why."
Logan: "The day after our report, and with the help of the U.S. Ambassador to Iraq, Captain John Gilliam and his men answered the doctor's emotional cry for help."
Soldier, by a building: "Dr. Quraish al-Kasir "
Soldier: "He's right there."
Dr. Quraish Fajir al-Kasir, peering out a doorway: "I'm here!"
Logan: "There was no time to waste."
Soldier: "Three coming out!"
Logan, over video of the family being guided into the armored vehicle: "The soldiers rushed the family to the safety of a Bradley armored fighting vehicle knowing an attack could come at any moment, the doctor's daughter clutching in her arms her most beloved possession [a dog]. Then the moment of relief and the gesture that said it all [Dr. Quraish Fajir al-Kasir inside Bradley waving kisses]. It took only minutes to reach the safety of the heavily fortified green zone, a short distance away. It will take the family much longer to recover after witnessing executions, neighbors and friends killed."
Dr. Quraish Fajir al-Kasir, on camera, in hard to understand English: "These are days that I will never forget in my life. Thank you American military, thank you people."
Logan: "For their rescuers, many on their second tour here-"
Dr. Quraish Fajir al-Kasir to a Marine: "It's wonderful, I will never forget it."
Soldier: "No problem, no problem."
Logan: "-it was a rare pleasure."
Sergeant Nicholas Skelton, Crazyhorse Troop, 4-9 Cavalry: "I've seen a lot of people get hurt and it's good to see a family we could save and make sure they didn't get hurt while they were out here."
Logan: "The next day, the doctor told me the family had decided to stay in Iraq. They believe their duty now is to try to help the families still trapped and terrified on Haifa Street. Lara Logan, CBS News, Baghdad."

"Bush Cheered at Fort Benning" v "Bush
Speaks & Base Is Subdued"

"Are There Two Different Fort Bennings?" So asked James Taranto in his Friday "Best of the Web Today" compilation for Opinion Journal.com as he cited an AP story posted on ABCNews.com with the headline, "Bush Cheered at Fort Benning," while the New York Times headline declared: "Bush Speaks and Base Is Subdued."

The headline and lead paragraph to a January 11 Associated Press dispatch: "Bush Cheered at Fort Benning: FORT BENNING, Ga. -- President Bush, surrounded on Thursday by cheering soldiers in camouflage, defended his decision to send 21,500 more U.S. troops to Iraq and cautioned that the buildup will not produce quick results. 'It's going to take awhile,' he said." See: www.abcnews.go.com

January 12 New York Times story: "Bush Speaks and Base Is Subdued: FORT BENNING, Ga., Jan. 11 -- President Bush came to this Georgia military base looking for a friendly audience to sell his new Iraq strategy. But his lunchtime talk received a restrained response from soldiers who clapped politely but showed little of the wild enthusiasm that they ordinarily shower on the commander in chief." Check: www.nytimes.com

Taranto's January 12 "Best of the web Today" column: www.opinionjournal.com

The CBS Evening News delivered the same spin the night before the New York Times story ran. Katie Couric characterized, on January 11, as "out of the ordinary" the "response the President got today from a usually receptive audience," soldiers at Fort Benning. Reporter Jim Axelrod checked in: "To start selling his plan, President Bush picked about the friendliest audience he could find -- soldiers at Fort Benning, Georgia. But even rallying the troops is now a challenge. The mood here was polite but muted, more somber than usual for a President talking to soldiers." For more, see the January 12 CyberAlert: www.mediaresearch.org

CBS Ignores Lower Count and Hypes Most
Dire Homeless Guesstimate

Two days after the National Alliance to End Homelessness released its survey which estimated that in January of 2005, "744,313 people experienced homelessness," the CBS Evening News on Friday picked an earlier, more dire, guesstimate covering an entire year from the group with a self-interest in making homelessness seem as ominous as possible. Introducing an "Assignment America" piece from Steve Hartman on a homeless shelter in Gloucester, Massachusetts that "could be a museum, or at least a bed and breakfast" since it's "350 years old and beautifully restored," fill-in anchor Russ Mitchell declared, "It's a sad truth: Too many Americans don't have a house to call their own. Over the course of any year, some 600,000 families find themselves homeless, and that includes more than 1.3 million children." On screen, viewers saw matching numbers attributed to the National Alliance to End Homelessness, but in a study released on Wednesday, the group reported that its month-long survey located "98,452 homeless families."

[This item was posted Friday night on the MRC's blog, NewsBusters.org: newsbusters.org ]

A page on the group's Web site contends: "Most Americans underestimate how the problem of homelessness affects families. About 600,000 families and 1.35 million children experience homelessness in the United States." See: www.endhomelessness.org

But for a report released on January 10, "Homeless Counts," the group used "local point-in-time counts of homeless people to create an estimate of the number of homeless people nationwide. As with all data, the counts included in this report are not perfect and have numerous limitations, but they are the best data available at this time." The organization determined that "in January 2005, an estimated 744,313 people experienced homelessness" as "59 percent of homeless people counted were single adults and 41 percent were persons living in families. In total, 98,452 homeless families were counted."

For the report: www.endhomelessness.org

Time Trashed Flat Tax in '96, Now Flat
Tax Boom In Eastern Europe

More than a decade after publisher Steve Forbes's flat-tax platform temporarily vaulted him to the top of the pack of GOP presidential candidates, another prospective Republican presidential candidate is making tax simplification a centerpiece of his 2008 campaign. In announcing his exploratory committee, Kansas Senator Sam Brownback argued, "We need a flat tax instead of the dreadful, incomprehensible tax code we now have," Monday's Wichita Eagle reported.

But unlike back in 1996, the media are now confronted with the evidence that the flat tax help boost wealth-producing economic growth. This week's Time reports on the economic boom in the former Soviet republic of Estonia, which like many Eastern European countries has seen its fortunes rise since dumping socialism and instituting a flat tax. "The economy is now one of Europe's most dynamic, racing along at an 11.3% growth clip," Peter Gumbel writes this week in his "Letter from Estonia." See: www.time.com

Nearly eleven years ago, Time took dead aim at Forbes's flat tax in a January 29, 1996 cover package, "Does the Flat Tax Make Any Sense," an issue which hit mailboxes right before the New Hampshire primary.

[This item, by Rich Noyes, was posted Monday afternoon on the MRC's blog, NewsBusters.org: newsbusters.org ]

Senior Editor Nancy Gibbs perfectly echoed the liberal establishment's disdain for both the flat tax and conservative economic theories: "The heart of his [Steve Forbes's] fiscal crusade is his flat tax, a plan derided as 'deja voodoo' by economists who blame Reagan's supply-side tax cuts for the explosion of the national debt. He has captured perfectly the fury Americans feel for a system they think treats them like suckers while the rich enjoy a secret tax code written just for them -- not withstanding his flat tax could favor the rich even more effectively." See: www.time.com

"The scheme Forbes is pushing in his television ads looks as if it would either swell the federal deficit or raise taxes on middle Americans while bestowing extra riches on the rich," echoed Time writer Dan Goodgame in a second piece headlined, "Is This Flat Tax Unfair?" See: www.time.com

Fast forward to this week's Time, which reported on the innovative and booming Estonian economy, without mentioning that U.S. taxpayers have to deal with a much more cumbersome system with far higher top rates. In fact, the biggest problem in Estonia seems to be an unemployment rate so low, the country is worried about a labor shortage. An excerpt of Gumbel's letter:

Since regaining independence in 1991 with the collapse of the U.S.S.R., Estonia (pop. 1.35 million) was the first former Soviet republic to introduce its own currency and adopt a flat-tax system, now widely copied in the rest of Eastern Europe. It has also become one of the most technologically advanced places on the planet. You can use your mobile phone to pay for parking, buy bus tickets or check your children's school schedule. Wi-fi hot spots are ubiquitous, and the nation's most famous start-up is Skype, the Internet phone titan, which eBay acquired for $2.6 billion. That's slightly more than the annual output of the entire Estonian economy 15 years ago.

The economy is now one of Europe's most dynamic, racing along at an 11.3% growth clip. Estonia is the only new European Union member to have a budget surplus, and its national debt is shrinking rapidly. Naturally, there are growing pains: the unemployment rate has fallen so sharply, from 14% in 2000 to about 4% today, that businesses are scrambling to find workers. "This is the best time in our history," says Sten Tamkivi, Skype's Estonian operations manager....

Most Estonians, enjoying a boost in living standards, are hoping the boom can continue. But there's at least one caveat: Estonia needs to resolve its labor shortage. "We are running out of people," says Craig Rawlings, president of the American Chamber of Commerce in Tallinn. Still, Estonia has shown that it can improvise. "We're a very small country," says Skype's Tamkivi. "That means we just have to be efficient." So far, they've managed.

END of Excerpt

The question is, if Brownback's candidacy takes off, will Time remember its own reporting on Eastern Europe's flat tax boom? Or will they once again go after the flat tax as a threat to liberals big government priorities?

"Top Ten Surprises in President Bush's
60 Minutes Interview"

From the January 15 Late Show with David Letterman, the "Top Ten Surprises in President Bush's 60 Minutes Interview." Late Show home page: www.cbs.com

10. Interview was conducted in the Camp David hot tub

9. President refused to talk about anything except Jennifer Hudson's performance in "Dreamgirls"

8. Announced his candidacy for the 2008 presidential election

7. While walking through the woods, constantly ducking Cheney buckshot

6. Vowed in the future he'll make much better mistakes

5. All the Heineken empties

4. Paused for a CIA briefing about likely Golden Globe winners

3. His Andy Rooney-esque rant about hard-to-open ketchup packets

2. Bush's tearful admission he bet entire United States budget on the Chargers

1. Just like Britney -- no underpants


# News media guests this week on the late night shows: Matt Lauer on Tuesday's Tonight Show with Jay Leno and his co-host, Meredith Vieira, is scheduled to appear on Wednesday's Tonight Show. Dan Rather will be on Friday's Late Show with David Letterman.

-- Brent Baker