Howard Kurtz Ridicules Media Freak Out on Sequester
CNN's Howard Kurtz mocked the media – including his own network – on Sunday's Reliable Sources for uncritically channeling government hysteria over the sequester cuts.
"[I]f the press had put in, let's say, 10 percent of the effort
that was devoted to investigating, I don't know, Beyonce's lip syncing
into the actual measurable effects of these budget cuts, I think we
would have seen a somewhat different picture," quipped Kurtz.
[Video below. Audio here.]
"I think there is room for a lot more skeptical reporting about the
impact of these budget cuts," he continued. One of the examples of media
hype that he provided was CNN anchor Suzanne Malveaux reporting that
"planes won't fly, trains are going to suffer, troops are going to feel
the belt tightening in all branches of the service."
Even uber-liberal Cenk Uygur, a former MSNBC host, agreed with Kurtz's
take: "'Everybody is getting fired. The world is on fire.' I don't
believe the government. I think that they're hyping it up. I think it's
politics."
As NewsBusters reported, CNN's hysteria included comparing the cuts to the asteroid, calling them a "man-made disaster," and relaying White House talking points hyping the effects of the sequester.
A transcript of the segment, which aired on Reliable Sources on March 3 at 11:12 a.m. EST:
HOWARD KURTZ: Let me get to the substance here in our remaining time. I
want to play for you a montage of clips of how television is covering,
and has been covering up until they took effect Friday at midnight, the
so-called sequester budget cuts.
(Video Clip)
BILL PLANTE, CBS News White House correspondent: The White House
stepped up its campaign to pressure Republicans, enlisting the Secretary
of Homeland Security to suggest that layoffs could make it more
difficult to prevent terrorist attacks.
ED SCHULTZ, MSNBC host: 10,000 teachers could lose their jobs. Airport
security could be cut by $323 million. 70,000 kids would be kicked off
Head Start.
SUZANNE MALVEAUX, CNN anchor: It means planes won't fly, trains are
going to suffer, troops are going to feel the belt tightening in all
branches of the service.
KIMBERLY GUILFOYLE, FOX News: Sequestration isn't going to mean
Armageddon for America. But the press and political class, mostly on the
left, are trying to tell you otherwise.
(End Video Clip)
KURTZ: You're nodding your head, Tim Carney. A lot of the reports,
particularly on television, adopting the Obama line that the sky is
going to fall?
TIM CARNEY, The Washington Examiner: Yep. And that the sky is
going to fall, that cats and dogs are going to be sleeping together, all
that stuff. And I mean, I saw NBC, I think they have an editorial
policy to use the word "massive" when they're talking about
sequestration.
KURTZ: Well, that's a lot money.
CARNEY: It's less than three percent of a cut. And so, yeah, I think they're way overplaying it.
CENK UYGUR, "The Young Turks": I actually agree with Tim, again, on
this issue. You know, I love Ed, but, come on. "Everybody is getting
fired. The world is on fire." I don't believe the government. I think
that they're hyping it up. I think it's politics.
KURTZ: I think there is room for a lot more skeptical reporting about the impact of these budget cuts. Washington Post
had a great front-page story the other day, which taking to task, among
other things, Education Secretary Arne Duncan who said, quote, "There
are literally now teachers who are getting pink slips." A little
investigation showed that was not the case.
We will see what the impact is, but if the press had put in, let's say,
10 percent of the effort that was devoted to investigating, I don't
know, Beyonce's lip syncing into the actual measurable effects of these
budget cuts, I think we would have seen a somewhat different picture.
-- Matt Hadro is a News Analyst at the Media Research Center
