TV's Increasing Female Body Count
Violence - especially grotesque, gory or bloody violence - has become
a staple of network television during sweeps periods. But there's a new
kind of violence surging - violence against women. A new study by the
Parents Television Council called "Women in Peril" reveals that between
2004 and 2009, CBS, NBC, and Fox (but not ABC) all green-lighted a
significant increase in the incidents - and degree - of violence
against women.
On average, during the five-year span there was a two percent
increase in overall violence during the prime time viewing hours. But
during the same time period there was a 120 percent increase in the
number of times the audience would be exposed to a violent scene with a
female victim.
CBS, the "CSI" network, led with 118 violent storylines on women,
but NBC had the largest increase, at 192 percent. The forms of violence
depicted included rape, stabbing, dismemberment, electrocution,
poisoning, shooting, beating, and torture. Death was regularly a result
of the violence.
This stat tells it all: In a complete reversal of tradition, network
programmers strongly favored violence depicted on screen (92 percent)
rather than implied (5 percent) or merely described (3 percent).
Flipping channels in prime time can be a scary proposition with
children in the room. Viewers of the NBC comic-strip-themed show
"Heroes" saw images in flashback of the villain Sylar's evil deeds,
including a scene of him stabbing a woman in the chest with scissors.
On ABC's popular and sleazy "Desperate Housewives," viewers were
shocked when one of the main female characters was shot in the chest
while camping in the woods. It turned out to be a murderer's daydream,
and his plot was conveniently foiled before he could kill off a major
character.
Nothing's sacred. A smaller, but growing category in network
sensationalism is violence against female children, virtually unseen in
the past (six incidents in the 2004 February and May sweeps). There
were 30 such scenes on the same networks during the same time slots in
2009. CBS's "CSI" featured a plot about a teenaged girl found dead in a
parking lot (with the corpse shown several times), and in flashback
scenes, viewers saw her assaulted by a friend's father. For good
measure, there was an attempted sexual assault while she was
unconscious. A gorier scene aired on NBC's "Medium," where a suspect
was shown photos of a teenage girl whose throat was slit and covered in
blood.
The acceptable rules of engagement for female characters keep
expanding. Chivalry is dead, and so are lots of women on television,
splayed in all kinds of horrific poses. Graphic violence and bloody
crime scenes were not necessary for people to enjoy "Police Woman" or
"Hill Street Blues." Now it's seemingly essential. It makes you
sentimental for the days of shows like "Mannix," where people would get
shot and fall down. Was it realistic? No. Neither was it horrific.
Then there's the bloody violence and brutality in cartoons. It's not
as "real," and therefore perhaps not as bothersome as live action,
perhaps, and because of that, it's far more gruesome.
Imagine what would have been the audience's reaction, children and
adults alike, a generation ago if, watching "The Flintstones," suddenly
Fred Flintstone were to smack Wilma in the face, or Bam-bam were to
pummel Betty Rubble with his stick.
Yet on today's prime time cartoons, aimed at adults and children
alike, the creators think it's hilarious to abuse their female
characters. On "Family Guy," the lead character tells his son that he
should be the "best leader of the household" he can. So the son pushes
his rear end into his sister's face and flatulates, and then punches
his mother in the face. On "American Dad," a female dentist saves the
lead character from a shooting. When she approaches for a hug, he
punches her in the face and takes her gun. See the "hilarious" pattern?
Then there's the bloody violence. On "Family Guy," a joke about the
"extensive divorce procedure required by 18th century society" is
illustrated by the lead character shooting his daughter dead with a
musket. On "American Dad," there's so-called comedy in suggesting lawn
sprinklers are a deadly household hazard. In a cautionary film, two
little girls are shown playing catch with a doll, when one girl trips
and lands on the sprinkler, which pokes through her chest cavity. The
sprinkler showers the house, lawn and the other little girl with blood.
The creator of those shows recently had his contract renewed, reportedly at $100 million.
