MediaWatch: November 1991

Vol. Five No. 11

Print Reporters Too

Just like their electronic colleagues, many newspaper and magazine reporters accused Republicans of playing dirty and the Democrats of being too nice:

"Just as they did in the 1988 campaign, the Republicans battered the other side by going ugly early with nasty, personal attacks, by successfully linking the Democrats with liberal advocacy groups and by using volatile images of race."
-- New York Times reporter Maureen Dowd in a page 1 news story, October 15.

"The White House went into those hearings with a clear strategy: they were going to get Clarence Thomas confirmed. And the Democrats came in, having been under a lot of heavy criticism for trying to cover up this whole story or whitewash it, and they said `we're going to be the seekers of the truth.' And so, Clarence Thomas has lawyers sitting on that committee who were working for him, and Anita Hill didn't have any, and in the end, the strategy worked for the Republicans."
-- U.S. News & World Report Asst. Managing Ed. Gloria Borger, Oct. 18 Washington Week in Review on PBS.

"The lowest point on the first day of the hearing came when Pennsylvania Republican Arlen Specter implied that Hill had simply fantasized Thomas' asking for dates and his lurid remarks about pornography. It is all but inconceivable that a similarly qualified man, black or white, would be accused not merely of lying but of imagining things."
-- Time Senior Editor Jack E. White, October 21 issue.

"The days of Simpson Chic are over. Now he is more often compared to Red-baiter Joe McCarthy. The image of Simpson flinging open his jacket and declaring he had lots of `stuff' against Anita Hill -- while revealing nothing -- was the lowest of many low points in the Clarence Thomas hearings. Any Senator with a sense of history should have said, as attorney Joseph Welch eventually did to McCarthy, `Senator, have you no shame?' ....[Simpson] is writing a book about the media -- a little like Stalin discussing intergovernmental relations."
-- Newsweek Washington reporter Eleanor Clift, October 28 news story.