Best of NQ 2012 Public Ballot

The Twenty-Fifth Annual Awards for the Year's Worst Reporting


Damn Those Conservatives Award

Winner

Allison Yarrow / Ramin Setoodeh (1232 votes)

Newsweek/Daily Beast assignment editor Allison Yarrow: “Can you imagine being that organ donor? I mean, it’s such a difficult decision to say ‘I want to give my body to someone else after I’m dead.’”

Newsweek senior writer Ramin Setoodeh: “To Dick Cheney? I would never give my heart to Dick Cheney. It would freeze over.”

Yarrow: “I would never do it. I’d say ‘give me my heart back.’ Exactly …”

Host/columnist John Avlon: “Seriously, the ill will toward Dick Cheney getting a heart transplant is stunning.”

Yarrow: “He may be one of the most evil people in the world.”

— Exchange on NewsweekDaily Beast’s daily “NewsBeast” Web show, March 26.


Runners-Up

Martin Bashir (1153 votes)

Host Martin Bashir: “When we last saw the Republican front-runner Rick Santorum speaking before a crowd yesterday, all we could think of was George Orwell’s novel 1984 about a society dominated by the most extreme form of totalitarianism….”

Clip from 1984: “The forces of darkness and the treasonable maggots who collaborate with them, must, can and will be wiped from the face of the Earth.”

Bashir: “In reviewing his book, It Takes a Family, one writer said, ‘Mr. Santorum has one of the finest minds of the 13th century.’ But I’m not so sure. If you listen carefully to Rick Santorum, he sounds more like Stalin than Pope Innocent III.”

— MSNBC’s Martin Bashir, February 14.


Lawrence O’Donnell (1149 votes)

“I want to see hard core Republican conservatism put up there on a debate stage with President Obama’s practical approach to governing, and I want to see hard core Republican conservatism crushed.”
— MSNBC’s Lawrence O’Donnell during live coverage of the Super Tuesday primaries, March 6.


Brooke Baldwin (806 votes)

“ObamaCare lives. Republicans did everything they could to chip away at the law in the two years since it was passed, and many were confident the Court would strike down the individual mandate. So for them, today’s ruling kind of has to sting. Senator Roy Blunt is one of those Republicans who was rooting for ObamaCare to fall. Senator, welcome. You lost in 2010 when this law was passed, you lost again today. Yet you are still pushing for the repeal of this law. Doesn’t that make you look kind of like a sore loser?”
— Anchor Brooke Baldwin on CNN’s Newsroom, June 28.


Charles Gibson (318 votes)

“Republican Congressmen have told me if they don’t sign it [anti-tax pledge] they’re dead, they’re gone. Well, that’s absurd, absolutely absurd. In one of the debates I thought there was a very good question asked about what kind of proportion would you take between tax cuts and revenue-raising taxes. Would you take $5 of revenue cuts for every dollar of new taxes? No, they said. How about ten-to-one? No. Twenty-to-one? No. Fifty-to-one? No. That’s absurd, that’s just absurd. You cannot tie yourself down that way, and I think it’s just a very good example of what’s wrong with the Congress right now.”
— Former ABC World News anchor Charles Gibson speaking at Quinnipiac University in Connecticut, September 20, video of which was later posted at the TVNewser blog.


Bill Keller (224 votes)

“Remember earlier in the campaign when Newt Gingrich was worrying everyone about Sharia law: the Muslims were going to impose Sharia law in America? Sometimes Santorum sounds like he’s creeping up on a Christian version of Sharia law.”
— Ex-New York Times Executive Editor Bill Keller, now a columnist for the paper, on MSNBC’s Morning Joe, February 28.