ABC Finds "Talk of a 7.2 Percent Growth Rate Falls Flat" --10/31/2003

1. ABC Finds "Talk of a 7.2 Percent Growth Rate Falls Flat"
The 7.2 percent annualized GDP growth rate for the third quarter, the highest since 1984, is great news, but. That's how the networks approached the news on Thursday night as they added caveats about the lack of job growth and doubts about whether the boom can last, though all acknowledged how Bush's tax cuts were a factor in spurring growth. ABC's World News Tonight countered the good news with bad news as Dean Reynolds highlighted a poll taken before the fresh number was announced: "An ABC News poll this week found that 71 percent of Americans think the economy is still bad." Reynolds warned: "So in places like Georgetown, South Carolina, where the local steel mill has cut 450 jobs since June, the talk of a 7.2 percent growth rate falls flat." ABCNews.com asked: "President Bush cut taxes to boost the economy, but at what cost?"

2. NPR Ombudsman Reacts to CyberAlert Item About Nina Totenberg
CyberAlert reader complaints about NPR reporter Nina Totenberg's hope on Inside Washington that Lt. General Jerry Boykin, who had talked about the war on terrorism as a war on Satan, is "not long for this world," led NPR Ombudsman Jeffrey Dvorkin to devote a online report to her comment. Dvorkin recounted her remarks and then outlined what happened next: "'Cyberalert!' The Media Research Center (motto: 'Tracking Liberal Media Bias Since 1996') immediately put out a 'cyberalert.' This is a call to supporters to send repeated e-mails saying how distraught, shocked and appalled they are." Not quite.

3. On 60 Minutes II Dan Rather Raises Jennings/Toby Keith Dispute
In a 60 Minutes II profile Wednesday night of country singer Toby Keith, Dan Rather brought up how ABC's Peter Jennings rejected having Keith sing his hit song, "Courtesy of the Red, White and Blue (The Angry American)," on ABC's 2002 prime time 4th of July special. Keith told Rather: "I don't like him." But when Keith recalled how he said at the time that "I bet Dan Rather wouldn't kick me off his show," Rather demurred from agreeing.

4. Letterman's "Top Ten Things Never Before Said By Wolf Blitzer"
As announced by CNN's Wolf Blitzer himself to people on the streets of Manhattan, Letterman's "Top Ten Things Never Before Said By Wolf Blitzer."

ABC Finds "Talk of a 7.2 Percent Growth
Rate Falls Flat"

The 7.2 percent annualized GDP growth rate for the third quarter, the highest since 1984, is great news, but. That's how the networks approached the news on Thursday night as they added caveats about the lack of job growth and doubts about whether the boom can last, though all acknowledged how Bush's tax cuts were a factor in spurring growth.

ABC and CBS noted how it was the biggest GDP jump in nearly 20 years or since 1984, but only NBC Nightly News anchor Brian Williams mentioned Ronald Reagan: "You'd have to go back to the Reagan years to find the last time the nation's Gross Domestic Product jumped this much."

While ABC, CBS and NBC led with the fresh GDP number announced Thursday morning, as did FNC's Special Report with Brit Hume, FNC's Fox Report and CNBC's The News with Brian Williams didn't get to it until after fire news, and CNN's NewsNight, which devoted its first half hour to the California fires, held itself to a very brief item read by anchor Aaron Brown.

Following its lead story on the GDP hike, ABC's World News Tonight countered the good news with bad news as Dean Reynolds highlighted a poll taken before the fresh number was announced: "Indeed, an ABC News poll this week found that 71 percent of Americans think the economy is still bad. In terms of expectations, only three in ten say things are improving." Reynolds warned: "So in places like Georgetown, South Carolina, where the local steel mill has cut 450 jobs since June, the talk of a 7.2 percent growth rate falls flat."

(The ABCNews.com Web site on Thursday was even more downbeat. The home page plug for World News Tonight: "The latest on California's devastating fires. Plus, President Bush cut taxes to boost the economy, but at what cost?" That was online at abcnews.go.com [1]
At "what cost"? World News Tonight did not answer that question. It stressed unemployment, but didn't blame the tax cuts for that -- so maybe a case of a Web site writer getting ahead of the bias.
The World News Tonight page headlined its GDP story, which was just a slightly different version of the Dean Reynolds piece which aired: "What Turnaround?" The subhead: "A new GDP reports a 7.2 growth rate in the economy, but that means little to people who remain unemployed." That was online at: abcnews.go.com [2] )

At the top of the NBC Nightly News, Brian Williams cautioned: "Today's figures show the nation's output of goods and services up 7.2 percent at an annual rate for the third quarter this year. In fact, today's number was so big, it didn't take long for some to question just how real it is and how long it will last."

NBC's Anne Thompson warned: "More jobs means more consumer spending and potentially more growth. But not even the President thinks the economy can keep expanding at this rate. Already, Advertising Age Editor Scott Donaton is seeing a change. The ad pages that bulked up fall magazines are shrinking for December and January."

But over on the CBS Evening News, Jim Axelrod saw just the opposite, signs of a job-creating business rebound: "On the factory floor they've been producing one giant disconnect the last few years. As workers dodge layoffs, politicians say better days lie just ahead. But now, says Wachovia's Mark Vitner looking at the latest numbers, believe it."

Below, more complete rundowns of the October 30 stories on the ABC, CBS and NBC evening newscasts as taken down by MRC analyst Brad Wilmouth:

-- ABC's World News Tonight. The opening tease from Peter Jennings: "On World News Tonight, from Washington, an unexpected surge in economic growth. Best quarter in 19 years. Did the tax cuts make a difference?"

Jennings, in Washington, DC, anchored with the White House in the background, but ABC had no sound for his first few words, so we join him in progress: "-good news about the economy. And it comes from the third quarter of the year -- July, August and September. The Gross Domestic Product, which is the broadest measure of economic activity, was up more than seven percent. That is the strongest growth for a single quarter in nearly two decades. And it was better than most estimates. This is very big news for millions of Americans, and big political news as well. They're very happy over there at the White House tonight. We're going to begin with our business correspondent, Betsy Stark."

Stark started: "The economy roared back to life this summer, and for the first time in a long time, business led the charge. Companies ratcheted up their spending by 11.1 percent, the biggest increase in three years. This advertising executive says she's finally feeling confident enough in the recovery to invest thousands in new computers."
Unidentified woman: "I feel able to spend because I see the dollars coming in, I see the projects and the contracts being signed. And I can project that it's not going to go away."
Stark: "The economy also got a boost from a 6.6 percent surge in consumer spending. Clarice Kennedy got the cash she spent fixing up her vacation home by refinancing her mortgage, spurred by the lowest interest rates in 45 years."
Clarice Kennedy: "I would say by the time we're done, we'll have put anywhere from $50,000 to $60,000 into the house."
Stark acknowledged the tax cut: "Most economists say the President's tax cut played a big part in Americans' third quarter spending spree."
Bruce Kasman, J.P. Morgan Economist: "Well, I think out of that 7.2 percent growth, if you wanted to parse it out, I think you'd have to argue that at least a percentage point, probably closer to two percentage points, could be attributed to the tax cuts."
Stark, however, cautioned: "But many also agree its impact is likely to be short-lived. Those who got tax credits have spent them, which leaves the question: 'What happens to the economy now?'"
Ed McKelvey, Goldman Sachs economist: "Tax cuts can motivate the consumer, they obviously did in the third quarter, but to sustain growth on a long-term basis, you need it to be organic, and organic means job growth generating strong income growth."
Stark: "The missing piece are still jobs. Despite a blockbuster growth rate, the economy continued to lose jobs in the third quarter -- 41,000 of them, Peter."

Jennings wondered: "Two questions about jobs. How can you continue to grow the economy without workers?"
Stark: "Well, in a word, productivity. Employers are managing to squeeze that much more out of their existing workers."
Jennings: "And what does it take, therefore, to create more jobs?"
Stark: "Well, not one quarter of spectacular growth, but several quarters of consistently strong growth, and economists think that that's where we're headed."

Jennings then showcased Bush's take: "Almost as soon as the economic numbers were released here today, the Bush administration was indeed taking credit. Here's what the President had to say."
George W. Bush in Columbus, Ohio: "The tax relief we passed is working. We left more money in the hands of the American people, and the American people are moving this economy forward."

Next, Jennings listed other positive numbers as he introduced a second story devoted to the lack of job growth and an ABC poll now superceded by the facts, but that didn't dissuade ABC from highlighting it: "There are various bright spots in this economy. Corporate earnings are improving, home sales are still very strong, mortgage rates are still relatively low, but there is still a lot of weakness, as Betsy Stark alludes, in the job market. Here's ABC's Dean Reynolds."

Reynolds began: "Even as they fuel the nation's economy, there was a certain hesitancy today among shoppers on Chicago's Magnificent Mile."
Man: "I'm spending money, yes. I'm not too confident in the economy right now. I haven't seen a lot of job creation."
Reynolds: "Indeed, an ABC News poll this week found that 71 percent of Americans think the economy is still bad. In terms of expectations, only three in ten say things are improving."
Woman: "I think unless people have jobs, they're not going to have confidence in the economy."
Reynolds: "So in places like Georgetown, South Carolina, where the local steel mill has cut 450 jobs since June, the talk of a 7.2 percent growth rate falls flat."
James Sanderson, US Steelworkers: "I don't know where they're getting those numbers from, but we're definitely not seeing that robust economy here in Georgetown, South Carolina."
Reynolds: "Devon Martin, who lost a $14 an hour job last week, was in the unemployment office at 8:30 this morning."
Devon Martin: "And I have never been in unemployment offices before in my life. This was the first time for that."
Reynolds: "Many economists believe the jobless rate of more than six percent is unlikely to decline for months as businesses maximize their profits for now with the reduced work force they still have on hand."
Paul Kasriel, Northern Trust Bank economist: "It is cold, it is cruel, but that's the way the world works."
Reynolds: "While manufacturing continues to slump, the transportation and service sectors are hiring again, but new jobs seldom pay as much as old ones. In Canton, Ohio, 55-year-old Jim Greathouse worked as a machinist for 30 years at $50,000 a year until he was laid off in the spring."
Jim Greathouse: "I've always been able to go it on my own, and, you know, with my own abilities and skills. Now it seems like they're not needed."
Reynolds concluded: "If the economy is really turning around, it can't happen fast enough for Jim. He bought his new home exactly one week before he lost his job."

For the online version of Reynolds' story: abcnews.go.com [3]

The October 29 ABCNews.com story on the poll, which Reynolds cited, began: "While George W. Bush said Tuesday the economy's 'gathering strength,' consumer confidence remains stalled, with recovery yet to hit home for many Americans. Seventy-one percent say the economy's in bad shape, miring the ABCNEWS/Money magazine Consumer Comfort Index in a long-running slump. The index stands this week at -18 on its scale of +100 to -100, its 23rd straight week between -16 and -21.
"That's worse than average - the index has averaged -9 in weekly polls since late 1985, and far below its highs of the late '90s through 2000. While the latest recession officially ended nearly two years ago, confidence reached its lowest point in nearly a decade last March (-28), and is now still well below its level during the 2001 recession."

That's online at: abcnews.go.com [4]

I'd say it's now Bush 1, consumer perception 0.

-- CBS Evening News. Dan Rather stuck to the upbeat as he led his broadcast: "The U.S. economy has produced some strong, very strong, and encouraging numbers for the third quarter of this year. Consumers went on a buying spree and business boomed. From July to September, the nation's Gross Domestic Product grew at an annual rate of 7.2 percent, an at least short-term pace not seen since 1984. And as CBS News economics correspondent Anthony Mason reports, President Bush took credit for the surge, citing it as a vindication of his much-debated economic policies."

Mason characterized the economy as "firing on all cylinders" with the highest GDP in 20 years. He noted how "campaigning in Columbus Ohio, President Bush credited his tax cuts for the turnaround."

But Mason balanced Bush with Lee Price of the liberal Economic Policy Institute, though he didn't offer any such label. Price cautioned: "Real output did go up a lot. That's not an illusion, but whether it can sustained or whether it's a flash in the pan is the question."

Mason maintained that "economists agree" that to sustain growth the economy must create new jobs. Mason concluded: "The President himself admitted today the economy can't keep growing at this blistering pace. Interest rates have been inching back up, those tax cuts have been spent, so with less money in people's wallets growth will slow. The question is does the economy now have enough momentum that the engine won't stall out again."

The tax credits may have been spent, but the lower tax rates will continue.

Next, Jim Axelrod saw an upbeat jobs future: "On the factory floor they've been producing one giant disconnect the last few years. As workers dodge layoffs, politicians say better days lie just ahead. But now, says Wachovia's Mark Vitner looking at the latest numbers, believe it."
Mark Vitner, Senior economist, Wachovia Securities: "Now I think that with the economy growing this strongly, we've got a recovery that virtually everybody will recognize as an economic recovery."

Axelrod, however, pointed out how in the last 30 months the private sector has shed 3.3 million jobs, with Carrier layoffs in Syracuse being the latest, and so lost manufacturing jobs might never come back.

-- NBC Nightly News. Brian Williams teased: "Rebound: The American economy shows its fastest growth in nearly 20 years. Will new jobs follow?"

Williams opened the newscast: "Good evening. It's about the only news that could knock the disaster in California out of the headlines tonight. There are dramatic new numbers on the economy. In fact, you'd have to go back to the Reagan years to find the last time the nation's Gross Domestic Product jumped this much. Today's figures show the nation's output of goods and services up 7.2 percent at an annual rate for the third quarter this year. In fact, today's number was so big, it didn't take long for some to question just how real it is and how long it will last. We begin here tonight with NBC's Anne Thompson."

Thompson: "The dramatic growth in the economy, fueled by both consumers and businesses spending money, and lots of it. The trends converging at Wes Smith's auto parts plant in Plymouth, Michigan. Here, sales of fasteners and seat brackets skyrocketed in August and September as Americans bought vehicles at a near record pace. Taking advantage of new tax breaks, Smith in turn bought $6 million worth of equipment to increase business."
Wes Smith, E&E Manufacturing Owner: "It not only creates opportunity for us, it secures jobs for our employees. It also secures our future."
Thompson: "In Ohio today, President Bush eagerly took credit for the good economic news, saying tax relief is working."
George W. Bush: "We're laying the foundations for greater prosperity and more jobs across America so that every one of our citizens has a chance to realize the American dream."
Thompson: "Economists credit the tax cuts and a surge in mortgage re-financings for the economy's biggest growth in almost 20 years, but caution both factors are one-time events. Far more troublesome is that all this growth came without jobs."
William Dudley, Goldman Sachs Chief U.S. Economist: "And if we don't start to see a meaningful pickup in job creation by say the first quarter of next year, then I would get quite nervous about the economic outlook."
Thompson: "More jobs means more consumer spending and potentially more growth. But not even the President thinks the economy can keep expanding at this rate. Already, Advertising Age Editor Scott Donaton is seeing a change. The ad pages that bulked up fall magazines are shrinking for December and January."
Scott Donaton: "They don't want to fully believe that the recovery is here until the money is in their hands, and the money's not in their hands, yet."
Thompson concluded: "Even Wes Smith admits he's cautious but optimistic, hoping the economy and his business will grow so they both can add jobs next year. Anne Thompson, NBC News, New York."

For the Department of Commerce's Bureau of Economic Analyis' press release on the GDP number: www.bea.gov [5]

For BEA's historic table: www.bea.gov [6]

NPR Ombudsman Reacts to CyberAlert Item
About Nina Totenberg

CyberAlert reader complaints about NPR reporter Nina Totenberg's hope on Inside Washington that Lt. General Jerry Boykin, who had talked about the war on terrorism as a war on Satan, is "not long for this world," led NPR Ombudsman Jeffrey Dvorkin to devote an online report to her comment.

Dvorkin recounted the exchange on the October 18 Inside Washington, though he mis-dated it as October 10, and then outlined what happened next: "'Cyberalert!' The Media Research Center (motto: 'Tracking Liberal Media Bias Since 1996') immediately put out a 'cyberalert.' This is a call to supporters to send repeated e-mails saying how distraught, shocked and appalled they are."

In fact, though CyberAlert has been around since 1996, the MRC, as the top of every CyberAlert announces, has been "bringing political balance to the news media since 1987. The MRC is the leader in documenting, exposing and neutralizing liberal media bias."

In addition, CyberAlert is a regular publication with multiple articles each day, not an e-mail dedicated to fueling complaints about one specific incident. And as CyberAlert readers know, I did not ask or suggest, and as a policy do not ask or suggest (or provide addresses for doing so), readers to complain to a media outlet about something I argued was biased or imbalanced.

So, whatever response Dvorkin got is a tribute to the industriousness and independence CyberAlert readers who tracked down Dvorkin and complained to him on their own.

An excerpt of NPR Ombudsman Dvorkin's October 29 "Media Matters" report in which he insisted that "'opinion' is not what NPR is about" and argued that it's a bad idea for NPR reporters to appear on opinion shows:

NPR Journalists: Pundits or Reporters? Time to Choose

On October 10, the normally sedate television program, Inside Washington, had this lively exchange among host Gordon Peterson, Colbert King and Charles Krauthammer -- both of The Washington Post -- and NPR's legal affairs correspondent, Nina Totenberg:

NINA TOTENBERG: The problem in Iraq is also that I think that the administration doesn't want to really fess up that there are some serious, serious problems that maybe even they didn't do everything perfectly. I mean, now they've got this guy who was the head of the intelligence section in the Defense Department who is being quoted as telling various groups while he's in uniform that this is a Christian crusade against Muslims who --

GORDON PETERSON: You're talking about Boykin, Gen. Boykin.

TOTENBERG: Gen. Boykin, and this is terrible. This is seriously bad stuff for us.

COLBERT KING: And the other thing about Boykin, he got it wrong. He said, God put George Bush in the White House. It's the Supreme Court that did it.

TOTENBERG: The Supreme Court put George Bush in the White House.

CHARLES KRAUTHAMMER: There were 5,000 yentas in Palm Beach who couldn't read the ballot. If that was not an act of providence, nothing is...

TOTENBERG: I hope he's not long for this world, because you can imagine --

PETERSON: You want a hit out on this guy or what? What is this, The Sopranos?

TOTENBERG: No, no. I mean, in his job. In his job, in his job, please, in his job.

"Cyberalert!"

The Media Research Center (motto: "Tracking Liberal Media Bias Since 1996") immediately put out a "cyberalert." This is a call to supporters to send repeated e-mails saying how distraught, shocked and appalled they are. NPR has sent out the following note to concerned listeners:

Ms. Totenberg was invited -- to share her opinions as a panelist on Inside Washington , a syndicated television talk show produced by the CBS affiliate in Washington, D.C., not associated with NPR. During this particular show, Ms. Totenberg expressed her view that General Boykin's remarks would put the U.S. at a disadvantage in dealing with Muslims in Iraq and elsewhere, and that he should be replaced. In no way did she wish any harm to General Boykin. I have attached the Inside Washington transcript in which Ms. Totenberg makes clear that she was talking about General Boykin's tenure in his job.

In my opinion, Totenberg made it abundantly clear that she was not calling for anything other than the resignation of Gen. Boykin. Those who insist that she MUST have meant otherwise are indulging in their usual attempt to demonize her and NPR.

But there is another implication....

Frequently NPR journalists speak in public or write op-ed pieces in which their personal positions are expressed, but should they?

The issue goes beyond the First Amendment right of NPR reporters. While no one denies that NPR employees have that right, it becomes more complicated when NPR journalists are asked for their opinions -- not as citizens -- but as NPR journalists.

Whenever an NPR journalist opines in public about issues in the news, the consequences are fraught, in my opinion.

-- First, it diminishes the ability of that journalist to be perceived by the public as fair and neutral....

-- Second, it implies that the NPR journalist is speaking for the entire organization....

-- Third, "opinion" is not what NPR is about. NPR is -- and should be seen to be -- about providing fact-based reporting. Opinions and commentaries on NPR newsmagazines are always provided by non-NPR journalists or other outsiders. This is as it should be. Other media may make their reputations on providing strong opinions. But this has not been part of NPR's mission.

Staying Reportorial

There is a danger whenever NPR reporters appear in other media that do not have the same standards of journalism....

NPR journalists should be speaking, as well as writing and appearing, in other media. It is good for NPR and for its journalists, but when they do it, they should maintain NPR standards....

END of Excerpt

For Dvorkin's item in full: www.npr.org [7]

For the October 20 CyberAlert which started this tempest: www.mediaresearch.org [8]

On 60 Minutes II Dan Rather Raises Jennings/Toby Keith Dispute

In a 60 Minutes II profile Wednesday night of country singer Toby Keith, Dan Rather brought up how ABC's Peter Jennings rejected having Keith sing his hit song, "Courtesy of the Red, White and Blue (The Angry American)," on ABC's 2002 prime time 4th of July special. Keith told Rather: "I don't like him." But when Keith recalled how he said at the time that "I bet Dan Rather wouldn't kick me off his show," Rather demurred from agreeing.

MRC analyst Brian Boyd caught the exchange during the October 29 piece aired a week before CBS will carry the Country Music Awards.

Rather reminded viewers: "But not everybody embraced the song. Weeks after 'Angry American' was released, producers for ABC television asked Keith to play a Fourth of July concert, a show hosted by newsman Peter Jennings."
Keith: "Then they come in, and start putting the show together. And Pete comes in and says, 'Who is, who does this Toby Keith think he is? And he is not singing this song on my show.'"
Rather: "Peter Jennings said that?"
Keith: "Peter Jennings said that."
Rather: "ABC disputes that Jennings said that. Instead, the problem, according to ABC, was that the network didn't want to start the show with a song that, at times, can be very angry."
Keith, singing at a concert: "Man, you'll be sorry that you messed with our US of A. We'll put a boot in your ass, it's the American way."
Rather: "For his part, Jennings was quoted as saying it was a pity about the Toby Keith issue. But that opening the show with that song, he says quote 'probably wouldn't set the right tone.'"
Keith: "I laughed."
Rather: "Did you?"
Keith: "Oh, I thought it was hilarious. My statement was, 'Isn't he Canadian?' to a bunch of press. They laughed and then I said, 'Well, I bet Dan Rather wouldn't kick me off his show.'"
Rather cryptically replied: "Well, I'm not gonna be hypocritical, you wouldn't want me to. I like Peter, he's a good guy."
Keith: "Well, I don't like him and I'll be honest with you, too."

Rather proceeded to raise a new lyric which has upset liberals: "For now though, he'll be busy promoting -- or shall we say -- explaining his newest album, due out next week. It's called 'Shock 'N Y'all,' and it contains more controversial songs, including "The Taliban Song."

Some of the lyrics: "I'm just a middle-aged, middle Eastern camel-herdin' man. I got a two-bedroom cave here in northern Afghanistan...So we prayed to Allah with all of our might and then those big U.S. jets come flyin' in one night. They dropped little bombs all over our holy land and man you shoulda seen 'em run, like rabbits, they ran: the Taliban."

For the online version of the story, with a video clip of it: www.cbsnews.com [9]

Letterman's "Top Ten Things Never Before
Said By Wolf Blitzer"

From the October 30 Late Show with David Letterman, as announced in taped segments by CNN's Wolf Blitzer himself to people on the streets of Manhattan, the "Top Ten Things Never Before Said By Wolf Blitzer." Late Show Web site: www.cbs.com [10]

10. "For a hundred dollars, I'll mention your name on CNN tonight"

9. "Have you seen Peter Jennings around here? That sum bitch owes me money"

8. "You know, it's a really slow news day today -- you wanna knock over a 7-11?"

7. "Saddam Hussein is in that Starbucks over there -- just keep it quiet"

6. "Once I got drunk at the CNN Christmas party and let's put it this way, the next day I woke up wearing Larry King's suspenders"

5. "Would you like to be the one hundredth person today to touch my beard?"

4. "You didn't hear it from me, but next week we're attacking Sweden"

3. "In case you missed last night's CNN newscast, let me give you the headlines...there's a major dispute between the hawks in the Bush administration, Don Rumsfeld, the Secretary of Defense, versus the doves, the Secretary of State Colin Powell. Let's review all the factual issues right now in this dispute"

2. I'm going on CNN in five minutes -- what's the Vice President's name again?"

1. [To a couple of women] "The Wolf is on the prowl, ladies"

# Les Moonves, President of CBS, is scheduled to appear tonight (Friday) on PBS's Charlie Rose show. This booking is timed to plug CBS's Sunday night 75th anniversary special, but maybe Rose will bring up the Reagan movie controversy.

# It's the last day of the month. If you haven't made a contribution yet to the MRC to help make CyberAlerts possible, how about doing so today, Halloween, so we can continue to put the scare into liberal reporters? A $25 donation works out to a mere ten cents per CyberAlert you receive, though don't hesitate to give more!

Use the direct link below to our convenient, safe and secure PayPal page, or follow the instructions to find the link on the MRC's home page.

-- Brent Baker [11]