According to CNN host Carol Costello, the White House failed to sell a
health care bill that could have been embraced by the American people,
many of whom "simply don't understand" the bill.
So during Monday morning's coverage of the Supreme Court hearings on ObamaCare's constitutionality, CNN explained some benefits the bill provides and gave the reason for the individual insurance mandate. Costello did her best impersonation of a White House advisor, explaining the bill's mandate to a public who doesn't understand it yet.
"And then another factor I think people don't quite understand about
the individual mandate, and this is from the Obama administration's
viewpoint, right? So if you force everyone to buy insurance that means
the insurance companies have more money, right? So that they can afford
to cover people with pre-existing conditions," Costello pointed out.
And CNN even provided fictional cartoon characters to explain the benefits of the individual mandate.
"So the individual mandate is going to help pay for people like Maria,
the musician," noted correspondent Elizabeth Cohen. "Maria only earns
$25,000. She will only have to pay $1,726 for insurance and then the
government is going to give a big subsidy. That's why that cost is so
low. The reason why the government can give the subsidy is because of
that individual mandate that you mentioned."
[Video below the break. Audio here [1].]
Costello faulted the Democratic leadership for the public's ignorance
of the health care bill. Apparently, the bill could have been embraced
by the public, but the White House just didn't sell it well enough.
White House correspondent Dan Lothian responded with another White
House perspective. "You know, messaging has been critical to a lot of
the misunderstanding, at least from the White House perspective, to
health care reform," he mused.
A transcript of the coverage, which began airing on March 26 on Newsroom at 9:02 a.m. EDT, is as follows:
[9:02]
CAROL COSTELLO (voice-over): The political fight over health care was
exhausting. Historic. On the day it passed, Democrats cheered. When
President Obama signed the law, Vice President Joe Biden inadvertently
told America just how amazing it was.
Vice President JOE BIDEN: This is a big f***ing deal.
COSTELLO: (voice-over) Was it ever. And still is in so many ways.
(...)
COSTELLO: (voice-over) All of this over a law many Americans simply don't understand.
(...)
COSTELLO: (voice-over) That's despite the fact that some aspects of the
law are now in effect. Children up to age 26 can stay on their parents'
plan. The prescription coverage gap for seniors is reduced. Insurance
companies cannot drop coverage for people with preexisting conditions.
States are allowed to cover more people on Medicaid. And new plans can't
charge for a certain preventive services like mammograms and
colonoscopies.
Actually the one aspect most Americans do understand is the requirement
that everyone have insurance, the widely-reviled individual mandate.
(...)
[10:09]
COSTELLO: You know what Dan, though? We talked to a lot of people. Most
Americans do not understand this law. They don't understand what's in
it. They don't understand what it means for them, and that largely is
this fault of the Democratic leadership, isn't it?
DAN LOTHIAN, CNN White House correspondent: You know, messaging has
been critical to a lot of the misunderstanding, at least from the White
House perspective, to health care reform. And, in fact, you heard the
President himself and other senior aides here in the White House say
that they have not been able to fully explain health care reform to the
American people. And that's why a lot of people – you look at the
polling, Americans are still divided about what they think about whether
or not there are benefits in this law for them.
And so certainly, there is a lot of reason for this White House to take
the blame for not messaging properly, explaining to American people how
they can benefit from this. But Republicans are saying, look, it
doesn't matter if they explain this, you know, from now until kingdom
come that they will never be able to convince them that this thing is
nothing other than a failure.
(...)
[10:39]
ELIZABETH COHEN, CNN senior medical correspondent: So let's take a look
at a couple of people who we invented to see how they're going to do
under health care reform and what will happen if the Supreme Court
changes all that. So I want to introduce you to my friend, Eddy the
Entrepreneur. So there he is. Eddy earns $80,000. He is an entrepreneur,
so he doesn't have an employer. So unlike you and me, he doesn't get
insurance through his employer. So under health care reform, eventually
what will happen is he will spend $4,500 on insurance. That's what he
would be required to pay.
And Carol, if he doesn't pay, look at that penalty there. He gets a
$2,000 penalty. So what this all rests on is what will people like Eddie
decide to do? Will they buy insurance, or will they pay the penalty?
The penalty costs less, right? But you don't get anything for it. If you
fork over more money, you actually get insurance. And if you want to
know how you can put in your income and you can figure out what this
means to you, go to cnn.com/empoweredpatient. We have a link to a
calculator. You can figure out what your insurance would cost and what
your penalty would be.
COSTELLO: And the reason the Obama administration wants this individual
mandate requirement is because it pays for the other things in the law.
COHEN: Exactly. Exactly. Because I want to introduce you to two other
people who need that payment. So the individual mandate is going to help
pay for people like Maria, the musician. Maria only earns $25,000. She
will only have to pay $1,726 for insurance and then the government is
going to give a big subsidy. That's why that cost is so low. The reason
why the government can give the subsidy is because of that individual
mandate that you mentioned.
Now, in her case, she will have a penalty of $695 if she doesn't – if
she doesn't, you know, pay – if she doesn't buy it. So, again, that's
going to be her choice and it will be fascinating to see what people do.
Will they pay $1,700 for insurance or will they pay $700 as a penalty?
Again, you don't get anything for that penalty. You just pay it and it
goes away.
COSTELLO: Okay. And then another factor I think people don't quite
understand about the individual mandate, and this is from the Obama
administration's viewpoint, right? So if you force everyone to buy
insurance that means the insurance companies have more money, right? So
that they can afford to cover people with pre-existing conditions. So
they can afford to do that.
COHEN: Right. The whole thing about the individual mandate is that if
you bring in everyone – okay, everyone – including healthy people, you
get more money in that pot. And that means, theoretically, that
insurance companies can afford to insure people with pre-existing
conditions.
Because before – or right now, if you have a – if it you're an adult
and you have a pre-existing condition and you try to get insurance on
your own, good luck to you. Because insurance companies are going to say
why should I insure you? You had a heart attack last year. Or even a
heart attack ten years ago. I don't want to pay to insure you. That's
going to be expensive.
Health care reform says, uh-uh, you've got to say yes to these people.
And where that money comes from to say yes to these people is the
individual mandate.
-- Matt Hadro is a News Analyst at the Media Research Center