CyberAlert -- 11/10/2000 -- Gore's "Moral High Ground" vs. Bush's "Hardball"

Gore's "Moral High Ground" vs. Bush's "Hardball"; Voter Victim: "My Arrows Didn't Line Up to My Buttons"; Franken: Bush "An Idiot" -- Weekend Edition [1]

1) Peter Jennings asserted: "It is a war out there. The presidential campaign only paused for election day." The networks suddenly found Pat Buchanan newsworthy as he made prime time.

2) CBS put the Gore camp on the moral and tonal high ground. John Roberts asserted that "leading in the popular vote, the Gore campaign believes it has the moral high ground." But Bill Whitaker asserted that though "the Bush camp wants to be seen as taking the high road....behind the scenes" they are "playing hardball."

3) ABC and NBC put the burden on the Gore team for escalating the rhetoric. ABC's Erin Hayes observed how Gore's "campaign generals today declared war" and reflected "outright disdain for George Bush." NBC's Tom Brokaw saw the Gore camp's "unmistakable and uncompromising language: We will not give an inch."

4) NBC's Bob Faw saw victims who "complained they too were tricked" by the ballot, showcasing a woman who whined: "I was thoroughly confused because my arrows didn't line up to my buttons." CBS highlighted a man who filed a lawsuit because "it was extremely difficult to figure out in fact which way to vote."

5) ABC's Cokie Roberts used the "S" word on the Late Show to describe the confused voters. CBS's Eric Engberg talked to a voting machine maker who observed: "You cannot make them idiot proof."

6) Al Franken on NBC's Late Night: "If it's Bush we should get behind him even though he's a business failure and a drunk til he was 40 and clearly did coke....The people will have spoken and...I hate him and he's an idiot."

7) Letterman's "Top Ten Ways the United States Would Be Different Without a President."

8) "As nervous as a cat in a room full of rocking chairs." Nope, Dan Rather didn't say it, but another network anchor did.

1

The ongoing presidential election saga again consumed nearly all of the broadcast network evening newscasts Thursday night while ABC and CBS dedicated prime time hours to the situation. CBS's 8pm ET/PT 48 Hours was devoted to the election as was ABC's 10pm ET/PT Prime Time Thursday.

It was also a big night for Pat Buchanan as his comment on Thursday's Today, that he believed most of his Palm Beach County votes were intended for Gore, suddenly made the networks interested in him after ignoring him for months. During the 9pm ET hour he appeared on CNN's Larry King Live, during the 10pm ET hour he popped up on ABC's Prime Time Thursday and MSNBC brought him aboard during its 11pm ET hour.

On the CBS Evening News, Dan Rather highlighted what Buchanan had said on Today: "Reform Party candidate Pat Buchanan said today he too believes most of the 3,000 votes he got in Palm Beach County were probably meant for Al Gore and Buchanan said he thought it was due to quote, 'ineptitude in the ballot design.'"

For a flavor of the network spin on the day, here's how ABC, CBS and NBC opened their Thursday, November 9 evening shows:

-- ABC's World News Tonight. Peter Jennings announced: "Good evening everyone. It is a war out there. The presidential campaign only paused for election day and while we're long way yet from a constitutional crisis, the whole nation is now engaged in debate about the election results...."

-- CBS Evening News. Dan Rather observed: "Good evening. The deadlocked presidential election is still in limbo tonight. It could be more than a week, perhaps longer than that, before we know whether we know Texas Governor George Bush or Vice President Al Gore is the next President."

-- NBC Nightly News. Tom Brokaw declared: "Good evening. It has never happened before, and it is a long way from over. An American presidential race that has now entered a new round of campaigning after election day because there still is no clear winner, and there are still votes to be counted in Florida and beyond. Here are the latest numbers from Florida as reported tonight by the Associated Press as it canvasses county by county. They say that George W. Bush has a lead that now has been reduced to 362 votes. However, the Secretary of State in Florida has just reported based on the returns that they have gotten so far that the George W. Bush lead is now more than 1700 votes."

2

CBS put the Gore camp on the moral and tonal high ground Thursday night. John Roberts asserted that "leading in the popular vote, the Gore campaign believes it has the moral high ground and they are casting the Bush campaign as so hungry to win that they will ignore the American voters." But in the very next story, Bill Whitaker stressed how "when top Bush aides came out today they came out firing" and though "the Bush camp wants to be seen as taking the high road....behind the scenes the Bush camp is playing hardball."

Dan Rather set up the back-to-back stories from Nashville and Austin: "With his lead holding, more or less, in the national popular vote totals, Vice President Al Gore is not giving up until there is a much closer look at the votes in Florida. And news from the Gore camp indicates that he's prepared to fight for at least another month. Gore campaign headquarters in Nashville keeps getting tuned up to more determination as the hours go by." [Yes, he said "tuned up to more determination"]

John Roberts portrayed a Gore team on the moral high ground:
"Gore's challenge of the re-count takes the country further into uncharted constitutional waters. But leading in the popular vote, the Gore campaign believes it has the moral high ground and they are casting the Bush campaign as so hungry to win that they will ignore the American voters."
Bill Daley: "In response to this clear injustice what does the Bush campaign say? They blithefully dismiss the disenfranchise of thousand of Floridians as being the usual sort of mistake made in elections." [Again, what he said]

Rather jumped to Bill Whitaker by simply acknowledging: "There's a different view in Austin." CBS had some problems with the tape for Whitaker's report jamming, but it began with him saying, "Since election night this Texas campaign has circled the wagons" and "when top Bush aides came out today they came out firing." After a tape re-cue, Whitaker explained two points from Karl Rove:
"Using blunt language, chief strategist Karl Rove claimed the number of spoiled ballots in Palm Beach County Florida and the high number of votes for Pat Buchanan there were not unusual. And those controversial, confusing butterfly ballots, similar to those used in the home county of Gore's chairman Bill Daley."
Karl Rove: "And it's historically been used in Cook County Illinois. Maybe Mr. Daley's in a better place to decry democracy and confusion in Cook County than he is in Florida."
Whitaker warned: "The Bush camp wants to be seen as taking the high road-"
Karen Hughes: "The country should look at the way the two campaigns are approaching this. We have approached this in a calm, in a thoughtful, in a responsible way."
Whitaker: "But behind the scenes the Bush camp is playing hardball, threatening to challenge Democrats in Iowa, Wisconsin and New Mexico, states where they claim voting irregularities helped Gore."

3

In contrast to CBS, ABC and NBC put the burden on the Gore team for escalating the rhetoric and lowering the tone. ABC's Erin Hayes observed how Gore's "campaign generals today declared war" and reflected "outright disdain for George Bush." NBC's Tom Brokaw saw the Gore camp's "unmistakable and uncompromising language: We will not give an inch."

Erin Hayes checked in from Tallahassee on ABC's World News Tonight: "For now, Al Gore is not only unwilling to concede, his campaign generals today declared war. They are making plans and raising money to fight on the legal front."

Hayes played clips from Bill Daley and Warren Christopher about alleged voter disenfranchisement in Palm Beach, before she described the atmosphere: "The tone was unmistakable: Outright disdain for George Bush."
Daley: "In response to this clear injustice what does the Bush campaign say? They blithefully dismiss the disenfranchise of thousand of Floridians as being the usual sort of mistake made in elections."
Hayes: "The response from the Republicans, at first measured, former Secretary of State Baker seeming to pay little heed to the Gore camp's charges....Later today though, back at the Bush camp, a tougher stance."
Viewers then saw a clip of Don Evans complaining you can't keep the vote going until your guy wins.

Up next, Terry Moran with Gore found a group "girding for battle" as "the rhetoric has escalated, there's a combative tone." Moran described a candidate doing what he has to for the best of motives: "They [aides] also say that he feels he owes it, as part of his duty and that's a very important concept to this candidate, to fight for the people who tried to vote for him."

Dean Reynolds with the Bush campaign found: "They're clearly worried, Peter, that these arguments about ballot box irregularities have been gaining some traction with the public. So today, as you heard, they went out and they denounced the Democrats as being shrill, distorting the political process. They said that the problems in Palm Beach County, for example, really aren't problems at all, that Democratic elected officials are the ones that ran that election. They looked at the ballots, they approved the ballots, they oversaw the voting..."

Referring to the Democratic lawsuits, later in the show Peter Jennings asked George Stephanopoulos: "I wonder if you think that the Democrats may not be on the verge of opening a big Pandora's box?"
Stephanopoulos replied: "We're not there yet, but it's certainly possible...."

Over on the NBC Nightly News, Tom Brokaw portrayed the Gore team as the ones lowering the tone: "The Gore campaign set the tone for the day when it's heavyweights appeared in Florida to make that legal and political case in unmistakable and uncompromising language: We will not give an inch."

Claire Shipman acknowledged the role of the media in Gore's plans: "Effectively starting a second campaign for the White House, this one in the court of public opinion."

4

Once again, the networks Thursday night reinforced Democratic rhetoric about how many Palm Beach County voters are victims not responsible for their own incompetence, as reporters relayed their protests without critical comment.

-- ABC's World News Tonight. Peter Jennings announced how Democrats say the "will of the people was thwarted." Steve Osunsami highlighted a protest march over the supposedly confusing ballot, adding as proof: "Buchanan won more votes here than in surrounding counties."
ABC then showed a man in the protest complain: "I may have voted for Buchanan, not realizing because of the confusion on the ballot."

Osunsami passed along how Democrats are upset that 19,000 double punched ballots were invalidated, "but Bush campaign officials point out that's similar to the 14,000 ballots thrown away in 1996."

Toward the end of his piece, some reason snuck in as during video of a clash between Bush and Gore supporters a man holding a Bush-Cheney sign yelled: "What happened here is absolute stupidity."

-- CBS Evening News. During his story on the re-count, Byron Pitts reported, without any context or comment about why: "The President of the NAACP wrote to the U.S. Attorney General requesting she send federal marshals into Florida to oversee the re-count."

Reporter Bobbi Harley got time for a full story on the protest and Jesse Jackson's call for a massive march. Out of all the people in the protest, she picked out the same guy as had ABC to showcase, this time with a name on screen. Jim Dwyer displayed his ignorance: "I really don't know who I voted for. When I went in I may have voted for Pat Buchanan who I did not want to vote for."
Harley backed him up: "In fact, Buchanan's vote totals show him spiking in Palm Beach County [3,407] as compared to Florida's other 66 counties. Democrats charge that it wasn't just a confusing ballot, it was an illegal one. Florida law states to quote, 'mark in the blank spot at the right of the name of the candidate for whom you desire to vote.'"
Lawyer Kendall Coffey maintained the ballot must be structured to avoid "confusion which resulted in the disenfranchisement of thousands and thousands of voters."
Harley found a victim: "One of those voters is Ron Lickman, who plans to file suit in state court asking for a new vote."
Ron Lickman, Florida voter: "And it was extremely difficult to figure out in fact which way to vote. Once you placed your vote it was too late."
Harley squeezed in a few seconds for the other side: "Republicans say the ballot was approved by both parties and overseen by Teresa LaPore, the county elections supervisor, and a Democrat. This afternoon as civil rights leader Jesse Jackson rallied a crowd outside."
Jackson: "Every vote counts!"
Harley: "LaPore was bunkered behind closed doors."

-- NBC Nightly News. Tom Brokaw announced, as transcribed by MRC analyst Brad Wilmouth: "And while all of Florida does remain in play, one county is getting most of the attention. Palm Beach County, a wealthy enclave on the East Coast where Gore voters insist they were confused by what they call an illegal ballot. As a result, 19,000 ballots were tossed out because they contained a double punch, or double votes, for presidential candidates. It is the center of what will surely be a historic political and legal dispute."

Bob Faw began: "In West Palm Beach, Florida, today, hundreds of voters take to the streets."
Woman protester: "The Republicans, they want to steal the presidency. This is no longer democratic action anymore."
Faw found some victims: "These voters want a new election in Palm Beach County, where election officials have tossed out those 19,000 ballots punched twice, cast by voters like Robert Hearst."
Robert Hearst, holding sign "My Vote Got Nixed": "I cast a vote for Gore, but at the same time I must have punched the Buchanan column as well."
Faw: "Even candidate Buchanan concedes those votes shouldn't be his."
Pat Buchanan, from Today show: "If the two candidates they pushed were Buchanan and Gore, almost certainly those are Al Gore's votes and not mine."
Faw: "Election officials have not announced how many of the double punched ballots went to Gore or Buchanan. Hundreds of other protesters also complained they too were tricked, that the ballot was so confusing when they tried to vote for Gore they actually voted for Buchanan."
Second woman protester: "I was thoroughly confused because my arrows didn't line up to my buttons."

Sounds like a personal problem to take up with her boyfriend, not the election commission.

Faw elaborated: "Buchanan received 3,407 votes in Palm Beach, County, three times as many as other Florida counties, including Pinellas, with the next highest Buchanan total. Lawyers for the Vice President say the whole process here was flawed."
Warren Christopher: "We've come to believe that there are serious and substantial irregularities resulting from the ballot used only in one county."
Faw: "Lawyers for Governor Bush argue the ballot was not confusing and that it met all legal requirements."
James Baker: "It is a ballot that was approved by an elected Democratic official. It is a ballot that was published in newspapers and hey, guess what, there were no complaints until after the election."
Faw concluded: "The question here is not how much noise disgruntled voters can make. It's how far the demands for that re-vote will be taken. One lawsuit was dismissed today as election officials said they'd start a new re-count here Saturday, with angry voters insisting they'll keep protesting till every vote counts."

As for how illogical the vote was, FNC's Jim Angle, on Special Report with Brit Hume, explained and assessed the Gore spin:
"They're making the argument, Brit, that they would get more if there were a re-vote, that somehow the current vote is illegitimate because they should have gotten more. They have two basic arguments about what happened in Palm Beach County. One is that 19,000 ballots were disallowed because people double punched or didn't punch the right place, that some way they cast a bad ballot. They're saying that is proof in itself that there was something wrong with this ballot. Now the only problem with that is that in 1996 there were 15,000 disallowed ballots and Pat Buchanan, this was not a problem with Pat Buchanan being on the ballot, so there's clearly something going on which is the number of disallowed ballots in every election.
"The second point is that they say, 'Look, Pat Buchanan got more than 3,000 votes in Palm Beach County. That is inconceivable. Clearly some people were confused because they couldn't possibly have intended to vote for Buchanan.' Well, the fact is Buchanan got 8,788 votes in that county in the Republican primary in 1996, so he does have support there, and the Reform Party candidate for Senate got the same number, about the same number of votes he got here this time, so it is conceivable that Pat Buchanan got that much support, but that's not the Gore campaign's argument. They're arguing they would have gotten enough votes to win if this vote had been different, and they would like it to be different."

5

ABC's Cokie Roberts used the "S" word on the Late Show to describe the confused voters, a thought that has yet to make it onto ABC News while CBS's Eric Engberg talked to a voting machine maker who observed: "You can make voting systems that are idiot resistant. You cannot make them idiot proof."

Roberts appeared on Thursday's CBS Late Show. When David Letterman asked her about people complaining about confusion about how to vote for Gore, Roberts maintained: "The sample ballots had gone out. The election officials had looked at them. People in both parties had had the opportunity to say we don't like this ballot, this ballot's confused."
Letterman: "Everybody signed off."
Roberts: "Everybody signed off on them. And at some point stupidity is not really an excuse."

The audience applauded her answer.

Earlier, on the CBS Evening News, Eric Engberg looked at how voting is mostly done utilizing old technology. He talked to John Seibel of True Ballot, Inc. about newer and better systems, including one which uses a computer screen, but Seibel cautioned: "You can make voting systems that are idiot resistant. You cannot make them idiot proof. As a very wise man once told me, if you make something idiot-proof they'll come up with a better idiot."

They certainly did in Palm Beach County.

6

Forget some voters being stupid or idiots, left-wing actor/writer Al Franken still sees George W. Bush as America's leading "idiot."

Thursday night he sat down with Conan O'Brien on NBC's Late Night and immediately pronounced: "We don't know who's going to be our next President. But when it's decided, whoever it is, we should all get behind that man. You know I'm for Gore, but if it's Bush we should get behind him even though he's a business failure and a drunk til he was 40 and clearly did coke, you know. The people, you know, the people will have spoken and you know, just, you know, I hate him and he's an idiot."

O'Brien's audience cheered his snide belittling.

7

From the November 9 Late Show with David Letterman, the "Top Ten Ways the United States Would Be Different Without a President." Copyright 2000 by Worldwide Pants, Inc.

10. Supreme Court justice selected by being 100th caller to Z-100
9. "Hail to the Chief" only played for winner of Pillsbury Bake-off
8. Instead of going to Iowa and New Hampshire every four years, no one would go to Iowa and New Hampshire ever
7. With no presidential fitness test, kids would be even fatter and lazier
6. White House interns would be reduced to having sex with each other
5. More time on news for banter between anchor and fat weatherman
4. The position of vice president would be even more insignificant
3. Entire country would operate as inefficiently as the state of Florida
2. Only her friends, family and an occasional guy from T.G.I. Friday's would know the name "Monica Lewinsky"
1. 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue would be the grandest Blockbuster Video ever

And from the Late Show Web page, some of the proposed items for the list which did not make the final cut:

-- To launch political career, Hillary forced to marry King of Norway
-- Teachers would say, "America is a place where any child can grow up and be...an accountant"
-- Instead of being on "The West Wing," Martin Sheen would be stuck playing a dead guy on "Diagnosis Murder"
-- In time of international unrest, soldiers ordered into combat by guy who played Colonel Potter on "M*A*S*H"
-- Goodbye President's Day mattress sale, hello Cher's Birthday mattress sale
-- Bill Clinton would get no action whatsoever

8

Was MSNBC anchor Brian Williams trying to mimic Dan Rather on election night? Just before midnight ET Tuesday night, MRC analyst Brad Wilmouth recalled, Brian Williams declared: "To quote a great man, both major presidential campaigns tonight as nervous as a cat in a room full of rocking chairs. Long tailed cat story."

If Dan Rather ever retires, CBS could hire Williams. -- Brent Baker [2]

>>> Support the MRC, an educational foundation dependent upon contributions which make CyberAlert possible, by providing a tax-deductible donation. Use the secure donations page set up for CyberAlert readers and subscribers:
http://www.mrc.org/donate [3]

>>>To subscribe to CyberAlert, send a blank e-mail to: mrccyberalert-subscribe
@topica.com [4]. Or, you can go to: http://www.mrc.org/newsletters [5]. Either way you will receive a confirmation message titled: "RESPONSE REQUIRED: Confirm your subscription to mrccyberalert@topica.com." After you reply, either by going to the listed Web page link or by simply hitting reply, you will receive a message confirming that you have been added to the MRC CyberAlert list. If you confirm by using the Web page link you will be given a chance to "register" with Topica. You DO NOT have to do this; at that point you are already subscribed to CyberAlert.
To unsubscribe, send a blank e-mail to: cybercomment@mrc.org [4].
Send problems and comments to: cybercomment@mrc.org [4].

>>>You can learn what has been posted each day on the MRC's Web site by subscribing to the "MRC Web Site News" distributed every weekday afternoon. To subscribe, send a blank e-mail to: cybercomment@mrc.org [4]. Or, go to: http://www.mrc.org/newsletters [5].<<<